PDA

View Full Version : Perhaps the price...


blueeyes
10-03-2003, 10:25 PM
I know that questions similar to this are asked commonly, however, I felt this needed to be addressed.

A common thread between one legend and the next states that a person, on becoming a werecreature, loses his or her soul. Although that will not affect the decisions any of those here, since few believe in such hocus-pocus, perhaps it should. It matters more how one defines the soul.
I've heard it said that, to create a true piece of art or music, one must put one's soul into the work. Any here who are particularly good artists or musicians or writers will all agree that some part of them must react with a work for it to truely be worthwhile.
But what of those who don't have that soul. Creativity, understanding, aesthetics. All would be lost. And I don't mean on the same scale as people who can't draw or just don't do well with an instrument. I mean to the level that studied drawing of a hand that still lacks the essence needed to portray its subject, or a couple slams on the guitar that sound like they were played on lead, or a speech that - despite hours of rehearsal - that sounds like it was merely rehearsed, not understood.
Can you believe such gifts could be lost in a single change? And what would that mean to you? Are you willing to learn, if the cost requires you to give up the ability to share that knowledge?
...
...
...
This all coming from a newbie who can't draw or play or... well, you've read my words. Anyway, share what you want to.

ThrasherCub
10-04-2003, 01:15 AM
a newbie? HI!
:wavey:
Well I'm the mystical type and am on a first-name basis with certain spirits and think the loss of a soul would be the most horrable thing ever. Thankfuly for me, I believe that the soul is REQUIRED to change. The way I figure it, the soul within you has at least some animal attributes - shifting is mearly bringing them to the surface.
But of course physicaly willing away the face you were born with is neigh impossible (sorry, I had to say that because my prior sentence made it sound too easy)


Es gibt nix
was es nicht gibt

blueeyes
10-04-2003, 08:44 AM
Thank you for sharing that. Do you have any opinions as to the questions I asked? They are merely theory, but I wanted to know.

LV426
10-04-2003, 01:37 PM
Can you believe such gifts could be lost in a single change? And what would that mean to you? Are you willing to learn, if the cost requires you to give up the ability to share that knowledge?

It is difficult to answer that because I really think a soul is a religious concept. Maybe I have a soul but I am not even sure what that soul is or does. What use is a soul? If I have a soul at this point I would give it up freely for something that I considered worthwhile. Shapechanging? well that is a rather nice concept and I think would be equal to the value of my non existant soul.

I'm artistic in certain ways but not outstandingly so. There would be little loss for me if what you say about a soul is true. But to me the soul does not make me who I am. I make myself, I am my own god, and I decide my own fate, and when I die, I die.

ThrasherCub
10-05-2003, 12:13 AM
simple run-down of my opinion
Existence requires nothing
Living requires spirit
Changing form requires a soul

Thank you, Thank you! Please! Don't clap, throw money!

Es gibt nix
was es nicht gibt